Erich Korngold: Symphony in F Sharp, Theme & Variations, Straussiana
"Out of the stuff of film music," said Alex Ross in a recent New Yorker article about Erich Wolfgang Korngold, "he fashions what may be the last great symphony in the German Romantic tradition." This new disc from John Wilson and the Sinfonia of London provides the most compelling version I've heard of Korngold's Symphony in F Sharp. I learn from the very fine liner notes by Brendan G. Carroll that Korngold worked on the Symphony during a holiday in Canada, but doesn't give any more details. I'll consult Carroll's 1997 biography The Last Prodigy to see if his Canadian itinerary is available, and report back here. In the meantime, I can fill in some plausible Canadian landscapes for a post-war holiday from Hollywood. Perhaps scenes from my neck of the woods: Victoria and Vancouver Island, and a train journey through British Columbia to beautiful Jasper National Park.
As it is, Korngold's usual movie-scene milieu is very much in evidence in the entire disc. Besides the usual Warner's back-lot, there are the Californian hills, forests and islands that stand in for Spanish, English and the Mediterranean adventure. One shouldn't have to apologize for film-score sourcing of "serious" classical music in the 21st Century, where very fine symphonic music is heard in every Multiplex, but alas, I've already read a number of reviews of this disc that are excessively patronizing. This is a Good Symphony by any standards (and a Very Good one in my view), and it's a serious error of categories to think it illegitimate because it comes from "the movies."
Besides the Symphony, there are two additional works on the disc. Both are appealing and accessible, and though they were written for the American School Orchestras Association, there's no lack of musical interest on the listening end. This new Korngold disc is something we've come to expect from John Wilson on Chandos: very fine American music played by superb British musicians in a completely authentic way.
Thank you for your very complimentary review; I am glad you found my notes helpful. Regarding Korngold's Canadian itinerary, I do indeed have these details, thanks to his many letters written to his Mother back in Hollywood, but such minutiae is not included in my book because it did not really add appreciably to the narrative. I would need to dig out those letters again (buried deep in my archive) to give you the specifics and when I do, I will send them along. One small correction if you do not mind, that is probably a typo - your heading in blue type lists 'Eric' rather than 'Erich' Wolfgang Korngold; could you please correct it? Korngold was highly sensitive about his name. Thanks again. BGC.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for this, Brendan!
ReplyDelete