The Certain and Uncertain Symphony

 Molécule - Symphonie no. 1, "Quantique"

"This symphony is an imaginary and symbolic representation made up of probabilities, intuitions, certainties and uncertainties. It is an artistic adventure charged with encounters, openness, benevolence and learning; its cardinal point is love for sound and its vibrations."
- Romain De La Haye-Serafini, aka Molécule

"All the good music has already been written by people with wigs and stuff."
- Frank Zappa 

This fascinating new symphony by the electronic musician Molécule was made in remarkable way. The composer attended rehearsals of the Orchestre National de Lille over a period of two years, recording everything: 

"... the sliding of strings, harmony, the cracking of instruments, silences, melodies, musicians’ breaths, the inaudible frequencies of a double bass... I wasn’t looking for perfect notes, but for a collection of sounds that would give me enough material to start composing."

This gave Molécule his sound palette. He took those sounds, manipulated them, and then recombined them into the standard four-movement symphonic format we all know and love. After he had created his soundscape, it was transcribed by Sinan Asiyan into standard orchestral notation, and played by the 83 musicians of the orchestra, led by its conductor Alexandre Bloch.

Molécule's earlier works involved a more adventurous sound recording stage; he gathered sounds in Arctic Greenland, and at the legendary huge waves of Nazaré in Portugal. But as he says in this video, the project with the Lille orchestra had its own artistic risks:

Molécule's sound-gathering is the most interesting and innovative part of both his earlier work and the Symphonie project. It might be analogous to Bartok or Villa-Lobos's ethnomusical forays into the Hungarian countryside and the Amazon rainforest. Meanwhile, the classical sound collage has been a staple of post World War II avant garde music: Mauricio Kagel's Ludwig Van, from 1969, is a good example:

But as cool as the process is, the proof of this particular pudding is in the music itself. There are certainly some impressive moments in the finished works, and I was swept up in some peak passages throughout. The problem with this kind of pastiche is also its strength: the best-sounding bits are the least original. There are plenty of modernist clichés and avant garde clichés and movie soundtrack clichés in this work. But of course, the parts that sound the most like John Williams or Howard Shore also sound like those composers' (acknowledged) forebears: Gustav Holst and Richard Wagner and Richard Strauss. Though Molécule actually samples particular works - for example, Debussy's La Mer and Holst's The Planets in Mouvement II, No. 3: 335 398 400 - most of the source material has been massaged so that only echoes of the original music can be heard.

Symphonie no. 1, in the end, can stand on its own as a success of outstanding process and workmanlike structure. Listen for yourself: